-61%
Anne Fadiman - The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down: A Hmong Child, Her American Doctors, and the Collision of Two Cultures

Anne Fadiman - The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down: A Hmong Child, Her American Doctors, and the Collision of Two Cultures

$15.00 $5.85 1 store
61% Off
Ask Friends for feedback
Smart Buy! Lowest price from a Trusted Store
$15.00 $5.85
61% Off
+ $3.99 shipping
3.9
Based on 7 user reviews
71% recommend this product
5 stars
2
4 stars
2
3 stars
3
2 stars
1 star
Share your thoughts
Write A Review

Consumer Reviews

Showing 1 - 7 of 7 Reviews

Sort by:
489

The Conflict Nobody Wanted

bymsiduri May 9, 2012
21 Helpfuls 22 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Detailed, evenhanded, sympathetic
Cons Author can wander from her point at times, but not too far
Recommended it? Yes

The subject of this book is Lia Lee, a Hmong child born in the States to parents who came to California as refuges from the war in Vietnam in 1980, a time when very little was known about Hmong culture among the American culture at large, much less American medical establishment. As an infant, Lia... Read full review »

218

Hmong Means Free Man

byonabreak2 Apr 18, 2005
19 Helpfuls 20 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Now Required Reading For Medical Students so they have a better understanding of...
Cons Would have liked Hmong terms written in English
Recommended it? Yes

This book is required reading for medical students according to the Hmong Interpreter where I work. It was the winner of the national book critic's circle award. Was praised by editors from the Washington Post to the New York times and many others. After you read it you will see why.

I... Read full review »

12

Smith's summer chore

bysimplyk8 Aug 1, 2001
17 Helpfuls 18 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros enthusiastic author, Smith reading, a different and culture, interesting idea
Cons Long; frequent strays from topic; awkward writing style; often nonsensical anecdotes
Recommended it? No

As an entering student at Smith College, I found myself immersed in the new life I would be coming into: excited about everything, planning my class loads, wondering what my roommate would be like, fretting about dorms, the right place on campus, and homework. When I found out we had summer reading... Read full review »

5

book will bring you into another culture

byvdeevanna Oct 19, 2006
15 Helpfuls 16 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros It is a fascinating story. Talks about how two cultures clash. Very informative.
Cons Fadiman often strays from the main topic.
Recommended it? Yes

I had to read this book for a class I'm taking this semester. This book is actually our university's "book of the semester. This book is very informative and will make you feel like you've stepped into another culture.

This book is about a clash between American doctors and the Hmong... Read full review »

16

It will make you think

bydov Dec 4, 2000
14 Helpfuls 15 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Absorbing Story
Cons Not always an "easy read"
Recommended it? Yes

This book is remarkable in that it manages to tell a compelling story about one little girl's epilepsy while, at the same time, offering a broad and moving expose about the cultural clash between Eastern and Western medicine.

The author of this book doesn't try to remove herself from the... Read full review »

6

A Typical One-Dimensional View

bynimh_rat Dec 1, 2007
8 Helpfuls 9 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Researched and wonderfully presented details of a very complex and high-staked situation.
Cons An romantic and uncritical--one-dimensional--look at the facts discovered.
Recommended it? Yes

"The Spirit Catches You…" is a worthwhile read for anyone interested in learning trivia about Hmong-Americans and, in particular, the tragic outcome for an epileptic Hmong-American child caught in the middle of an epic clash between her Hmong parents' orthodoxy, her American doctor's cultural... Read full review »

12

Smith Summer Reading a chore

bysimplyk8 Aug 1, 2001
8 Helpfuls 9 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Interesting idea, Smith summer reading, a different point of view and culture
Cons Long; frequent strays from topic; awkward writing style; often nonsensical anecdotes
Recommended it? No

As an entering student at Smith College, I found myself immersed in the new life I would be coming into: excited about everything, planning my class loads, wondering what my roommate would be like, fretting about dorms, the right place on campus, and homework. When I found out we had summer reading... Read full review »

Available From

Smart Buy! Lowest price from a Trusted Store

+ $3.99 shipping
Store Note: Used, +$4.99 Shipping

Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down - Anne Fadiman - 9780374525644 - 0374525641

ISBN13: 9780374525644. ISBN10: 0374525641. by Anne Fadiman. Published by MacMillan Higher Education. Edition: 97

Stock Availability: In stock
Store Note: Used, +$4.99 Shipping
Base Price: $15.00 $5.85
Tax:
Shipping: $3.99
Total Price: $9.84

Prices are provided by the merchants. We assume no responsibility for accuracy of price information provided by merchants. Please alert us to any pricing discrepancies and we will alert the merchant. Sales taxes are estimated at the zip code level. Shipping costs are estimates. Please check store for exact shipping costs. To learn more about why certain stores are listed on the site, click here

Product specifications are obtained from third parties, and while we make every effort to assure the accuracy of product information, we do not assume any liability for inaccuracies. Store ratings and product reviews are written and submitted by online shoppers to assist you as you shop. They do not reflect our opinions. We take no responsibility for the content of ratings and reviews submitted by users.

Copyright © 2000-2012 Shopping.com

http://img.shoppingshadow.com/jfe/JavaFrontEnd-fe118.rtb14.p1-8321
http://img.shopping.com/jfe/JavaFrontEnd-fe118.rtb14.p1-8321